Spectacle, spectacle, subalternity - discursive negotiations of identity and alterity in the context of popular knowledge media (1850-1950)
Summary
1. The sub-project examines the special role of Gypsy figures and representations in travel and adventure novels as well as in popular performance media such as opera, popular theatre and world exhibitions in France between 1850 and 1950, focusing on the intermedial interactions between the media.
2. Secondly, the project explores how these forms of representation are presented as knowledge formats that establish Gypsy figures as the ‘Other’ of modernity, focussing in particular on the spectacular as a central mode of representation of popular knowledge transfer.
3. Thirdly, special attention is paid to the ambivalences and paradoxes of the spectacular stagings of alterity, which, in addition to the codification of subalternity in recourse to heterostereotypes, also exhibit a potential for subversion that offers those described from the outside options for self-presentation through rewriting and reappropriation.
Research questions
1. Which metamorphoses and transformations do the representations of Gypsy figures undergo in the media analysed, which have hardly or not at all been examined with regard to Gypsy representations to date?
2. What is the relationship between the staging of alterity, the figuration/circulation of knowledge and media reflexivity on the basis of a closer examination of the aesthetics of the spectacular and its significance for modernity?
3. What interfaces arise with the other sub-projects that deal with the inclusion and exclusion effects of hetero-stereotypical representations in the arts and media or expository and journalistic texts? How can the ‘discovery/conquest’ of the foreign other and the scenography of its display be outlined? What functions do these assume in the general discourse of knowledge? What is the relationship between antiziganism and agency?
Cooperations
with other projects: The stagings dealt with in sub-project 2 interact with the visual media analysed in sub-projects 1 and 3 (stereotype, spectacle, scenography, display). The concept of knowledge circulation and popular knowledge media will be explored in more detail in cooperation with sub-project 4 with regard to knowledge genesis, narrativisation and circulation of this knowledge (emancipatory/defamatory potentials of representations of others). Interfaces with regard to self-empowerment through forms of self-presentation (agency) arise in particular with sub-project 5.
with other institutions: Together with Rom e.V. (Cologne), exhibitions on the interplay of external and self-representations of Sinti*zze and Rom*nja as well as readings/performances by writers/artists of the minority are planned.
Conference: ‘Circulation of Knowledge and the Aesthetics of the Spectacular’ in Giessen, organised by sub-projects 2 (von Hagen) and 4 (Bohn).
Investigation areas
Core investigation area: France
Additional area: Spain
Aims
AIM 1 - to investigate the function of Gypsy figures as borderline and negotiating figures of European modernity.
AIM 2 - to discuss the question of the extent to which Gypsies and Roma are merely objects (keyword subalternity) or also subjects (keyword agency) of spectacular productions.
AIM 3 - to analyse the interaction between the media and discourses and the formative potential of media and epistemological processes more clearly than previous research.
Fields of work
Using literary, cultural and media studies methods, the sub-project analyses spectacular Gypsy productions in literary texts (1), performance and exhibition media (theatre, opera, world exhibitions) (2), locates them in the context of popular knowledge media and places them in the context of self-articulations of Sinti*zze and Rom*nja (3)
1: examines literary texts such as adventure novels, novellas and travelogues as media and ‘vehicles’ of a world exploration that goes hand in hand with spectacular descriptions of ‘others’. It examines which stereotypes and topoi are used and circulate as popular knowledge within the majority society.
2: is dedicated to Gypsy representations in exhibition and performance media. It examines how, in the context of popular forms of performance such as the opera/ette, féerie or vaudeville, constructions of alterity are staged multimodally as alternative knowledge formats and how the curiosity for the unknown, the unusual and the spectacular is catered for.
3: looks at written and performative self-articulations of Roma in their interrelationships with the representations of others examined in Fields I and II. It asks how Roma insert themselves into the knowledge circulating about them and into spectacular modes of representation and subject themselves to rewriting or re-appropriation.
Selected results
- Habilitation: ‘Exclusion as a staging effect? Spectacle and World Exhibitions’, NN
- Monograph: ‘Faszinosum und Tremendum: Zigeuner-Figuren in populären Genres’, von Hagen
Prof. Dr Kirsten von Hagen
Justus Liebig University Giessen
Professor of French and Spanish Literature and Cultural Studies
Further information on the university website